STOpS successfully found optimal trajectories for the Mariner 10 mission and the Voyager 2 mission that were similar to the actual missions flown. STOpS did not necessarily find better trajectories than those actually flown, but instead demonstrated the capability to quickly and successfully analyze/plan trajectories. The analysis for each of these missions took 2-3 days each. The final program is a robust tool that has taken existing techniques and applied them to the specific problem of trajectory optimization, so it can repeatedly and reliably solve these types of problems.
This is a long-overdue volume dedicated to space trajectory optimization. Interest in the subject has grown, as space missions of increasing levels of sophistication, complexity, and scientific return - hardly imaginable in the 1960s - have been designed and flown. Although the basic tools of optimization theory remain an accepted canon, there has been a revolution in the manner in which they are applied and in the development of numerical optimization. This volume purposely includes a variety of both analytical and numerical approaches to trajectory optimization. The choice of authors has been guided by the editor's intention to assemble the most expert and active researchers in the various specialities presented. The authors were given considerable freedom to choose their subjects, and although this may yield a somewhat eclectic volume, it also yields chapters written with palpable enthusiasm and relevance to contemporary problems.
This book explores the design of optimal trajectories for space maneuver vehicles (SMVs) using optimal control-based techniques. It begins with a comprehensive introduction to and overview of three main approaches to trajectory optimization, and subsequently focuses on the design of a novel hybrid optimization strategy that combines an initial guess generator with an improved gradient-based inner optimizer. Further, it highlights the development of multi-objective spacecraft trajectory optimization problems, with a particular focus on multi-objective transcription methods and multi-objective evolutionary algorithms. In its final sections, the book studies spacecraft flight scenarios with noise-perturbed dynamics and probabilistic constraints, and designs and validates new chance-constrained optimal control frameworks. The comprehensive and systematic treatment of practical issues in spacecraft trajectory optimization is one of the book’s major features, making it particularly suited for readers who are seeking practical solutions in spacecraft trajectory optimization. It offers a valuable asset for researchers, engineers, and graduate students in GNC systems, engineering optimization, applied optimal control theory, etc.
Improvement of spacecraft trajectory optimization approaches, methods, and techniques is critical for better mission design. Preliminary low-fidelity analysis precedes high-fidelity analysis to efficiently explore the space of a problem. The work of this dissertation extends an embedded boundary value problem (EBVP) technique for preliminary design in the two-body problem. The EBVP technique is designed for direct, unconstrained optimization using many, short-arc, embedded Lambert problems that discretize the trajectory. The short arcs share terminal positions to implicitly enforce position continuity and the instantaneous velocity discontinuities in between segments are the control. These coasting arcs and impulsive maneuvers in between segments are defined collectively as a coast-impulse model, similar to the well-known Sims-Flanagan model. Use of EBVPs is not new to spacecraft trajectory optimization, extensively used in primer vector theory, flyby-tour design, direct impulsive-maneuver optimization, and more. Lack of fast and accurate BVP solvers has prevented the use of the EBVP technique on problems with more than dozens of segments. For the two-body problem, a recently-developed Lambert solver, complete with the necessary partials, enables the extension of the EBVP technique to many hundreds to thousands of segments and hundreds of revolutions. The use of many short arcs guarantees existence and uniqueness for the Lambert problem of each segment. Furthermore, short arcs simultaneously approximate low thrust and eliminates the need to know the structure of a high-thrust impulsive-maneuver solution. A set of examples show the EBVP technique to be efficient, robust, and useful. In particular, an example using 256 revolutions, 6143 segments, and a constant flight time per segment, optimizes in 5.5 hours using a single processor. After this initial demonstration, the EBVP technique is improved by a function which enables variable flight time per segment. Guided by the well-known Sundman transformation, these piecewise Sundman transformation (PST) functions divide the total flight time of the trajectory into spatially-even arcs, importantly not modifying the dynamics. Flight-time functions and their dynamical regularization counterpart are shown to share similar behavior for Keplerian orbit propagation. The PST functions are also shown to extend the EBVP technique to a large design space, where a runtime-feasible transfer with 512 revs and 12287 segments is presented that significantly changes semimajor axis, eccentricity, and inclination. Moreover, another example is presented that transfers through the numerically challenging parabolic boundary, i.e. a transfer from a circular to hyperbolic orbit. Both these examples use an exponent of 3/2 for the PST to enforce the spatially-even arcs or equal steps in eccentric anomaly. Lastly, an optimal control problem is formulated to solve a class of many-revolution trajectories relevant to the EBVP technique. For transfers that minimize thrust-acceleration-squared, primer vector theory enables the mapping of direct, many-impulsive-maneuver trajectories to the indirect, continuous-thrust-acceleration equivalent. The mapping algorithm is independent of how the direct solution is obtained and the mapping computations only require a solver for a BVP and its partial derivatives. For the two-body problem, a Lambert solver is used. The mapping is simple because the impulsive maneuvers and co-states share the same linear space around an optimal trajectory. For numerical results, the direct coast-impulse solutions are demonstrated to converge to the indirect continuous solutions as the number of impulses and segments increase. The two-body design space is explored with a set of three many-revolution, many-segment examples changing semimajor axis, eccentricity, and inclination. The first two examples change either a small amount of semimajor axis or eccentricity, and the third example is a transfer to geosynchronous orbit. Using a single processor, the optimization runtime is seconds to minutes for revolution counts of 10 to 100, while on the order of one hour for examples with up to 500 revolutions. Any of these thrust-acceleration-squared solutions are good candidates to start a homotopy to a higher-fidelity minimization problem with practical constraints
A collection of analytical studies is presented related to unconstrained and constrained aircraft (a/c) energy-state modeling and to spacecraft (s/c) motion under continuous thrust. With regard to a/c unconstrained energy-state modeling, the physical origin of the singular perturbation parameter that accounts for the observed 2-time-scale behavior of a/c during energy climbs is identified and explained. With regard to the constrained energy-state modeling, optimal control problems are studied involving active state-variable inequality constraints. Departing from the practical deficiencies of the control programs for such problems that result from the traditional formulations, a complete reformulation is proposed for these problems which, in contrast to the old formulation, will presumably lead to practically useful controllers that can track an inequality constraint boundary asymptotically, and even in the presence of 2-sided perturbations about it. Finally, with regard to s/c motion under continuous thrust, a thrust program is proposed for which the equations of 2-dimensional motion of a space vehicle in orbit, viewed as a point mass, afford an exact analytic solution. The thrust program arises under the assumption of tangential thrust from the costate system corresponding to minimum-fuel, power-limited, coplanar transfers between two arbitrary conics. The thrust program can be used not only with power-limited propulsion systems, but also with any propulsion system capable of generating continuous thrust of controllable magnitude, and, for propulsion types and classes of transfers for which it is sufficiently optimal the results of this report suggest a method of maneuvering during planetocentric or heliocentric orbital operations, requiring a minimum amount of computation; thus uniquely suitable for real-time feedback guidance implementations. Markopoulos, Nikos and Calise, Anthony J. Unspecified Center AIRCRAFT GUIDANCE; CONTROLLERS; FLIGHT PATHS; OPTIMAL CONTROL...
The direct approach for trajectory optimization was found to be very robust. For most problems, solutions were obtained even with poor initial guesses for the controls. The direct approach was also found to be only slightly less accurate than the indirect methods found in the literature (within 0.7%). The present study investigates minimum-time and minimum-fuel low-thrust trajectory problems via a single shooting direct method. Various Earth-based and interplanetary case studies have been examined and have yielded good agreement with similar cases in the literature. Furthermore, new near-optimal trajectory problems have been successfully solved. A multiple-orbit thrust parameterization strategy was also developed to solve near-optimal very-low-thrust Earth-based transfers. Lastly, this thesis examines the use of the high-accuracy complex-step derivative approximation method for solving low-thrust transfer problems. For certain very nonlinear transfer problems, the complex-step derivative approximation was found to increase the robustness of the single shooting direct method.
