La restitution des biens publics culturels aux États étrangers

La restitution des biens publics culturels aux États étrangers

Author: Charles Colomar

Publisher: Editions L'Harmattan

Published: 2022-07-06

Total Pages: 163

ISBN-13: 2140270991

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Il n'existe à ce jour aucun texte légal en droit interne qui fait application de critères communs à la restitution de biens culturels. Chaque restitution se règle, au cas par cas, par le biais d'un accord bilatéral entre la France et l'État qui en fait la demande conduisant ainsi à une profusion de législations particulières à l'image de la loi de restitution de têtes maories à la Nouvelle-Zélande ou celle des biens pillés au Bénin et au Sénégal lors de la colonisation. La problématique des restitutions se limite souvent à des aspects de morale, de justice ou de diplomatie. Pour autant, le principal frein aux restitutions est juridique. Deux doctrines s'opposent à la possibilité d'un retour des biens culturels à leurs pays d'origine : l'approche propriétariste et l'approche domaniste. L'intérêt grandissant de ce sujet dans le débat public et l'apparition de nouvelles théories de droit international invitent à refondre le régime juridique de la restitution des biens culturels aux États étrangers.


State Succession in Cultural Property

State Succession in Cultural Property

Author: Andrzej Jakubowski

Publisher: OUP Oxford

Published: 2015-06-04

Total Pages: 386

ISBN-13: 0191058009

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

The demise and rebirth of states brings with it a set of very complicated legal issues, among which is the question of how to deal with that state's cultural heritage, whether within its boundaries or not. Through a historical analysis of state dissolution and succession and its impact on cultural heritage from 1815 to present day, the work will identify guiding principles to facilitate the conclusion of agreements on the status of cultural property following the succession of states. Studying primary materials and evidence of state practice that has not been available before, the work will propose a novel approach to state succession from the perspective of the emerging interest of the international community to safeguard cultural heritage. State succession is one of the most obscure areas of international law since its rules are characterized either by their absence or their inconsistency. This book explores to what extent the principles and practice of state succession correspond to the evolution of the concept of cultural heritage in international law. It provides an extensive analysis of the alternations of the international practice and legal doctrine of state succession to tangible cultural heritage since the formation of the European nation-states in the nineteenth century - through the experience of decolonization to the post-Cold War dissolution of multinational states. The book has been awarded Prize of the Professor Manfred Lachs Foundation and Kozminski University in Warsaw for the best monograph in public international law published by a Polish author in 2015, in the category of debuts. On 24 November 2016, the book State Succession in Cultural Property by Andrzej Jakubowski was awarded the Prize of the Professor Manfred Lachs Foundation and Kozminski University in Warsaw for the best monograph in public international law published by a Polish author in 2015, in the category of debuts.


La restitution des biens culturels en cas de trafic illicite

La restitution des biens culturels en cas de trafic illicite

Author: Gauthier Vannieuwenhuyse

Publisher: Editions Universitaires Europeennes

Published: 2015-01-27

Total Pages: 112

ISBN-13: 9783841746351

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Cette etude vise a analyser l'obligation en droit international de restitution des biens culturels en cas de trafic illicite (vol ou exportation illicite) au travers de son histoire conventionnelle, notamment la Convention de l'UNESCO de 1970 et la Convention d'UNIDROIT de 1995. Cette etude revele cependant qu'il existe de nombreuses limites a la mise en uvre du regime de restitution de ces biens."