Essays on Competition in Electricity Markets

Essays on Competition in Electricity Markets

Author: Ricardo Javier Bustos Salvagno

Publisher:

Published: 2012

Total Pages: 322

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Chapter two examines the Chilean experience on auctions for long-term supply contracts in electricity markets from 2006 to 2011. Using a divisible-good auction model, I provide a theoretical framework that explains bidding behavior in terms of expected spot prices and contracting positions. The model is extended to include potential strategic behavior on contracting decisions. Empirical estimations confirm the main determinants of bidding behavior and show heterogeneity in the marginal cost of over-contracting depending on size and incumbency.


Managing Unilateral Market Power in Electricity

Managing Unilateral Market Power in Electricity

Author: Frank A. Wolak

Publisher: World Bank Publications

Published: 2005

Total Pages: 27

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

"This paper first describes those features of the electricity supply industry that make a prospective market monitoring process essential to a well-functioning wholesale market. Some of these features are shared with the securities industry, although the technology of electricity production and delivery make a reliable transmission network a necessary condition for an efficient wholesale market. These features of the electricity supply industry also make antitrust or competition law alone an inadequate foundation for an electricity market monitoring process.


Essays on Empirical Analysis of Multi-unit Auctions -- Impacts of Financial Transmission Rights on the Restructured Electricity Industry

Essays on Empirical Analysis of Multi-unit Auctions -- Impacts of Financial Transmission Rights on the Restructured Electricity Industry

Author: Hailing Zang

Publisher:

Published: 2005

Total Pages:

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

This dissertation uses recently developed empirical methodologies for the study of multi-unit auctions to test the impacts of Financial Transmission Rights (FTRs) on the competitiveness of restructured electricity markets. FTRs are a special type of financial option that hedge against volatility in the cost of transporting electricity over the grid. Policy makers seek to use the prices of FTRs as market signals to incentivize efficient investment and utilization of transmission capacity. However, prices will not send the correct signals if market participants strategically use FTRs. This dissertation uses data from the Texas electricity market to test whether the prices of FTRs are efficient to achieve such goals. The auctions studied are multiunit, uniform-price, sealed-bid auctions. The first part of the dissertation studies the auctions on the spot market of the wholesale electricity industry. I derive structural empirical models to test theoretical predictions as to whether bidders fully internalize the effect of FTRs on profits into their bidding decisions. I find that bidders are learning as to how to optimally bid above marginal cost for their inframarginal capacities. The bidders also learn to bid to include FTRs into their profit maximization problem during the course of the first year. But starting from the second year, they deviated from optimal bidding that includes FTRs in the profit maximization problems. Counterfactual analysis show that the primary effect of FTRs on market outcomes is changing the level of prices rather than production efficiency. Finally, I find that in most months, the current allocations of FTRs are statistically equivalent to the optimal allocations. The second part of the dissertation studies the bidding behavior in the FTR auctions. I find that FTRs' strategic impact on the FTR purchasing behavior is significant for large bidders - firms exercising market power in the FTR auctions. Second, trader forecasts future FTR credit very accurately while large generators' forecasts of future FTR credit tends to be biased upward. Finally, The bid shading patterns are consistent with theoretical predictions and support the existence of common values.


Market Performance and Bidding Behaviors in Deregulated Electricity Market

Market Performance and Bidding Behaviors in Deregulated Electricity Market

Author: Zhigang Liao

Publisher:

Published: 2012

Total Pages: 484

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

The objective of this research is to investigate the impact of different pricing rules on the economic performance of a deregulated electricity market. In particular, the influence on the bid prices and profits of generators, total dispatch cost, and the volatility of these values will be examined.Given the debate, over the past two decades, regarding the selection of the best pricing rules, the applicability of the Revenue Equivalence Theorem in the deregulated electricity market is revisited in this research. This theorem has been adopted in the literature as a theoretical support for deciding pricing rule in the market settlement process. In this research, it is hypothesized that the Revenue Equivalence Theorem may not hold. Therefore, it is appropriate to analyze market performance when different pricing rules are imposed to govern the market. Furthermore, this research also highlights the importance of generators bidding strategies in the competitive electricity market. The different methods used to design generators bidding strategies as presented in the literature have been reviewed.In order to investigate the different impact of pricing rules on market performance, this research employs a computer simulation method. A simulation platform is used to imitate the business activities in the electricity auction market, mainly in relation to the bidding, scheduling and dispatching processes. An agent-based approach is adopted for this purpose. The competing generators in the electricity market are modeled as agents. Bid stacking is used to model the optimization process of the Independent System Operator. The generator agents bidding strategies are designed using the Q-Learning algorithm. A Q-Learning-driven generator agent enables it to actively learn from the historical and market information leading to more realistic and practical results. Different pricing rules under both maximum quantity bidding and variable quantity bidding are studied separately. The influence on the bid prices and profits of generators, total dispatch cost, and the volatility of these values are analyzed accordingly.


Network and Temporal Effects on Strategic Bidding in Electricity Markets

Network and Temporal Effects on Strategic Bidding in Electricity Markets

Author: Youfei Liu

Publisher: Open Dissertation Press

Published: 2017-01-27

Total Pages:

ISBN-13: 9781361470282

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

This dissertation, "Network and Temporal Effects on Strategic Bidding in Electricity Markets" by Youfei, Liu, 劉有飛, was obtained from The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong) and is being sold pursuant to Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0 Hong Kong License. The content of this dissertation has not been altered in any way. We have altered the formatting in order to facilitate the ease of printing and reading of the dissertation. All rights not granted by the above license are retained by the author. Abstract: of thesis entitled "Network And Temporal Effects On Strategic Bidding In Electricity Markets" Submitted by Youfei Liu for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Hong Kong in February 2006 The global deregulation of power industries has given rise to many fascinating research topics. This thesis addresses issues of strategic bidding by power generators. The problem of strategic bidding is to optimize an individual power generation bid by maximizing profits, based on production cost, expectation of rival behavior and system demand. Electrical power flow over different links is governed by the physical law (Kirchhoff law). As a result, electrical power flow cannot be independently determined and the electricity transmission system has global network effects. One major contribution of this study is to investigate the network effects of electricity transmission on strategic bidding and analyze the network-constrained electricity market equilibria. A three-node electricity system is used for investigation. The decision space of generators is divided into the congestion-on region and congestion-off region, and the optimal response curves of generators in each region are then derived. The market equilibrium is located as the intersection of these optimal response curves. It is analytically shown that this may consist either of a unique unconstrained market equilibrium, a unique constrained market equilibrium, multiple-equilibria, or no pure Nash equilibrium. Subsequently, the interaction between transmission rights holding and market power exercising is addressed. It is shown that in the situation with a positive PTDF, holding transmission rights mitigate market power, and produce an improvement in market efficiency, while in other situations, the reverse is true. Furthermore it is demonstrated that a possible allocation of transmission rights to generators can be found to achieve maximum efficiency. Another unique characteristic of electricity markets is their notable temporal ii effects. In other words, electricity prices have significant volatilities because of the non-storability of power energy and the large variations of system demand. The second part of this study investigates the temporal effects of the electricity market on strategic bidding. A periodic dynamic feedback system is proposed to model the generation competition process. With the developed system dynamics, an optimal control problem is formulated to study the multi-period optimization behavior (called the 'advanced' strategy) of a generator, and the state-feedback control rule is then derived via a sweeping method. It is demonstrated that the generator with optimal control can obtain more profits, and a sensitivity analysis is provided to locate the market factors that affect the performance of optimal control. Next, system uncertainties are included, and a stochastic optimal control problem for generation decision is formulated and solved. Two interesting problems are investigated, namely the effect of the generator's 'advanced' strategic behavior on market efficiency, and the way in which an individual's payoff evolves with other generators' 'advanced' strategic behavior. It is shown that the 'advanced' strategic behavior of generators will improve market efficiency, while an individual's payoff evolution resembles a 'Prisoner Dilemma'. An analysis of risk management of generation decisi...


Market Design, Bidding Rules, and Long Memory in Electricity Prices

Market Design, Bidding Rules, and Long Memory in Electricity Prices

Author:

Publisher:

Published: 2004

Total Pages:

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

In uniform price, sealed-bid day-ahead electricity auctions, the market price is set at the intersection between aggregate demand and supply functions built by a market operator. Each day, just one agent - the marginal generator - owns the market-clearing plant. Day-ahead auctions are moreover embedded in multi-segment systems, wherein diverse protocols coexist and change over time. Such a complex environment leads to adoption of simple, adaptive bidding rules. Specifically, such a market design lets two different types of routines emerge, depending on whether the agent is a likely marginal or inframarginal generator. However, because of the uniform price mechanism, only the bidding behavior of the former can be reflected into market prices. Depending on the specific way marginal generators process past information to set their bids - 'hyperbolic' or 'exponential' - electricity prices are likely to display long- or short-memory. Experimental evidence on hyperbolic discounting - a quite robust behavioral bias in humans - supports a long-memory view of electricity prices. This insight is broadly confirmed by spectral analysis of daily data from NordPool and CalPX markets, in sharp contrast with most previous empirical studies. This paper underlines the importance of institutional settings in determining market outcomes, and an interesting mapping of bidding rules and models of information processing into the time series properties of market prices. -- Market Design ; Electricity Markets ; Hyperbolic Discounting ; Long Memory ; Fractional Processes


Electricity Markets

Electricity Markets

Author: Sayyad Nojavan

Publisher: Springer

Published: 2021-03-11

Total Pages: 270

ISBN-13: 9783030369811

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

This book analyzes new electricity pricing models that consider uncertainties in the power market due to the changing behavior of market players and the implementation of renewable distributed generation and responsive loads. In-depth chapters examine the different types of market players including the generation, transmission, and distribution companies, virtual power plants, demand response aggregators, and energy hubs and microgrids. Expert authors propose optimal operational models for short-term performance and scheduling and present readers with solutions for pricing challenges in uncertain environments. This book is useful for engineers, researchers and students involved in integrating demand response programs into smart grids and for electricity market operation and planning. Proposes optimal operation models; Discusses the various players in today's electricity markets; Describes the effects of demand response programs in smart grids.