Developing a Quantitative Multi-criteria Method of Sustainability Assessment

Developing a Quantitative Multi-criteria Method of Sustainability Assessment

Author: Giuseppe Tommaso Cirella

Publisher:

Published: 2010

Total Pages: 414

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Abstract : Sustainability science primarily emerged from the severe global events that had and were unfolding approximately a quarter century ago; evidence from the literature review conducted in Chapter 1 exemplifies this point. From this situation surfaced a number of concepts and techniques that have been tested and continue to be assessed. The first step of the methodology is the literature review in which the overall picture of the discipline is established and what direction sustainability related science is headed. The literature review found that the forefront of this research endeavours to adapt quantitative sustainability concepts into a method that can assess and analyse a geographical area. To undertake this challenge, the index of sustainable functionality (ISF) model is used via a quantitative multi-criteria method. This method of sustainability assessment establishes a historical and current state of functionality within a geographical area by producing a trend-like record. In sustainability terms, the ISF model uses an approach that calculates the adaptive quantitative results of a geographical area over a record period of time; the methodology in Chapter 2 describes the model's concept of assessment by way of actions via societal performance and ranking. The structure of the model is based on an engineering viewpoint; its key components umbrella a societal framework that encompasses an intertwined relationship using a triple bottom line (TBL) approach. The formation of this model is founded on a number of aspects, ideas and methodologies based on initial models of sustainability assessment. These initial forms to mention a few include environmental accounting, integrated assessment and ecological footprint have helped to establish the current settings of the discipline of sustainability science and the significance of related research. The methodology is broken down into two main components: (1) structure methodology which is framed around five steps that identify and define variables and (2) mathematical formulation which is used to calculate ISF records. An examination of the formulae used, also shows evidence that the principal ideas can be linked to a redefinition of sustainability; this is not the intention of this study, though in a quantitative sense the use of an action being functional or dysfunctional within society can be interpreted in this way. Actions include perspectives, functions and indicators, and sub-indicator(s); the analysis process is limited to the use of two types of data: datasets based on indicators and sub-indicator(s) used to formulate functions and data from the weightings process, that being, from the expert panel and the community telephone questionnaires. The data from the weightings process utilises the formulated functions and is the basis for the formulation of the system- vi perspective cross-reference matrix. This design is a stepladder process methodology and is the fundamental concept of the ISF's multi-criteria assessment. This report has two applications that examine the Australian regions of South East Queensland (SEQ) and the State of Queensland; the proposed index-based model is tested over a time span of 25 years from 1980 to 2005. The primary focus of the methodology is aimed at the SEQ region, acting as the mode's core focus for its experimentation and development. The SEQ region is broken down into four sub-regions which encompass a total of eighteen councils using the council structure from pre- 15 March 2008. For these regions ISF records are developed and analytically discussed as results in Chapter 3. The results, once merged, form the ISF of SEQ and detail a slow-to-moderate increase in level of functionality. The result in sustainability terms formulate an increase in functional growth rate of 15.38%, equating to an average annual growth rate of 0.62%. For the span of the study this is positive result, showing evidence of a growth in knowledge and awareness of sound TBL measures region-wide. As an extension to the SEQ study, an ISF application of the entire State of Queensland is conducted in Chapter 4. The ISF of the State of Queensland is a case study that uses similar methodology and structure to the SEQ project and demonstrates the applicability and scalability of the model at large. For the State of Queensland, the ISF result closely mirrors its smaller SEQ corner; it is inferred that since SEQ is partially the concluding ISF result of the State application, similar ISF records would be produced. In addition to the main report, there are six annexes that further detail, support and explain subject matter and findings throughout the dissertation (Annex 1 thru 6). Due to the length of the annexes they have been included as supplementary material. As the key contributing factor of this report, the development of an ISF model, using a quantitative multi-criteria method, reveals a transposable approach to assessing other areas within Australia and internationally. It is this transposability via produced traceable records that current and future generations may better utilise decision-making and managerial planning when considering the sustainable development crisis. The intentions of this report is not to produce a solution to this crisis, it is aimed at adding to the knowledge base of the sustainability science and promoting a cleaner, safer society with sustainable higher standards of living that support future generations. From this standpoint, it is hopeful that the methodologies utilised in this report can further the interdisciplinary work and help bring together technical, communicative innovation in a vital field of research.


Sustainability Assessment

Sustainability Assessment

Author: Alan James Bond

Publisher: Routledge

Published: 2013

Total Pages: 298

ISBN-13: 0415598486

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Currently the writing on the subject is limited and comprises, for the most part, guidance documents and completed assessments.


Sustainability as a Multi-criteria Concept

Sustainability as a Multi-criteria Concept

Author: Luis Diaz-Balteiro

Publisher: MDPI

Published: 2020-11-23

Total Pages: 206

ISBN-13: 3039435450

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Sustainability is a fairly old concept, born in the 18th century in the field of forestry, within a mono-functionality perspective. The concept has considerably evolved in the last few years towards a multi-functionality context, with applications reported in practically all areas of economic interest. On the other hand, modern sustainability is a complex problem, for two reasons: a) The multiplicity of functions of a very different nature involved in the process and b) The manner in which different segments of the society or stakeholders perceive the relative importance of these functions. For the above reasons, a realistic approach for dealing with the sustainability issue requires taking into consideration multiple criteria of different nature (economic, environmental and social), and in many cases within a participatory decision making framework. This book presents a collection of papers, dealing with different theoretical and applied issues of sustainability, with the help of a modern multi-criteria decision-making theory, with a single as well as several stakeholders involved in the decision-making process. Hopefully, this material will encourage academics and practitioners to alter their research in this hot and vital topic. After all, the sustainable management of the environment and its embedded resources is one of the most important, if not the major challenge of the 21st century.


Methods in Sustainability Science

Methods in Sustainability Science

Author: Jingzheng Ren

Publisher: Elsevier

Published: 2021-08-05

Total Pages: 446

ISBN-13: 012824240X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Methods in Sustainability Science: Assessment, Prioritization, Improvement, Design and Optimization presents cutting edge, detailed methodologies needed to create sustainable growth in any field or industry, including life cycle assessments, building design, and energy systems. The book utilized a systematic structured approach to each of the methodologies described in an interdisciplinary way to ensure the methodologies are applicable in the real world, including case studies to demonstrate the methods. The chapters are written by a global team of authors in a variety of sustainability related fields. Methods in Sustainability Science: Assessment, Prioritization, Improvement, Design and Optimization will provide academics, researchers and practitioners in sustainability, especially environmental science and environmental engineering, with the most recent methodologies needed to maintain a sustainable future. It is also a necessary read for postgraduates in sustainability, as well as academics and researchers in energy and chemical engineering who need to ensure their industrial methodologies are sustainable. Provides a comprehensive overview of the most recent methodologies in sustainability assessment, prioritization, improvement, design and optimization Sections are organized in a systematic and logical way to clearly present the most recent methodologies for sustainability and the chapters utilize an interdisciplinary approach that covers all considerations of sustainability Includes detailed case studies demonstrating the efficacies of the described methods


Sustainability Appraisal: Quantitative Methods and Mathematical Techniques for Environmental Performance Evaluation

Sustainability Appraisal: Quantitative Methods and Mathematical Techniques for Environmental Performance Evaluation

Author: Marina G Erechtchoukova

Publisher: Springer

Published: 2015-04-12

Total Pages: 0

ISBN-13: 9783642446788

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

One of the most important issues in developing sustainable management strategies and incorporating ecodesigns in production, manufacturing and operations management is the assessment of the sustainability of business operations and organizations’ overall environmental performance. The book presents the results of recent studies on sustainability assessment. It provides a solid reference for researchers in academia and industrial practitioners on the state-of-the-art in sustainability appraisal including the development and application of sustainability indices, quantitative methods, models and frameworks for the evaluation of current and future welfare outcomes, recommendations on data collection and processing for the evaluation of organizations’ environmental performance, and eco-efficiency approaches leading to business process re-engineering.


Situation-Oriented Approach Selection for Sustainability Assessments

Situation-Oriented Approach Selection for Sustainability Assessments

Author: Jan Bitter-Krahe

Publisher: Apprimus Wissenschaftsverlag

Published: 2021-04-01

Total Pages: 210

ISBN-13: 3863599640

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Sustainability assessments are important instruments for shaping sustainable development in all domains. However, not every assessment approach is fitting for every assessment situation. The fit between approaches and situations is rarely considered in the current practice of approach selection. In this thesis, a situation-oriented Multi-Criteria Decision-Making framework to support systematic selection decisions is developed and effects of selection on assessment results are investigated.


A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infrastructure Design

A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infrastructure Design

Author: Ignacio J. Navarro

Publisher: Infinite Study

Published:

Total Pages: 17

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Given the great impacts associated with the construction and maintenance of infrastructures in both the environmental, the economic and the social dimensions, a sustainable approach to their design appears essential to ease the fulfilment of the Sustainable Development Goals set by the United Nations. Multicriteria decision-making methods are usually applied to address the complex and often conflicting criteria that characterise sustainability. *e present study aims to review the current state of the art regarding the application of such techniques in the sustainability assessment of infrastructures, analysing as well the sustainability impacts and criteria included in the assessments. Analytic Hierarchy Process is the most frequently used weighting technique. Simple Additive Weighting has turned out to be the most applied decision-making method to assess the weighted criteria. Although a life cycle assessment approach is recurrently used to evaluate sustainability, standardised concepts, such as cost discounting, or presentation of the assumed functional unit or system boundaries, as required by ISO 14040, are still only marginally used. Additionally, a need for further research in the inclusion of fuzziness in the handling of linguistic variables is identified.


Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Techniques for Improvement Sustainability Engineering Processes

Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Techniques for Improvement Sustainability Engineering Processes

Author: Edmundas Kazimieras Zavadskas

Publisher: MDPI

Published: 2020-12-15

Total Pages: 490

ISBN-13: 3039367781

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

The success of any activity and process depends fundamentally on the possibility of balancing (symmetry) needs and their satisfaction. That is, the ability to properly define a set of success indicators. The application of the developed new multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) methods can be eliminated or decreased by decision-makers’ subjectivity, which leads to consistency or symmetry in the weight values of the criteria. In this Special Issue, 40 research papers and one review study co-authored by 137 researchers from 23 different countries explore aspects of multi-criteria modeling and optimization in crisp or uncertain environments. The papers propose new approaches and elaborate case studies in the following areas of application: MCDM optimization in sustainable engineering, environmental sustainability in engineering processes, sustainable multi-criteria production and logistics processes planning, integrated approaches for modeling processes in engineering, new trends in the multi-criteria evaluation of sustainable processes, and multi-criteria decision-making in strategic management based on sustainable criteria.


Waste-to-Energy

Waste-to-Energy

Author: Jingzheng Ren

Publisher: Academic Press

Published: 2020-05-26

Total Pages: 406

ISBN-13: 0128163941

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Waste-to-Energy: Multi-criteria Decision Analysis for Sustainability Assessment and Ranking offers a comprehensive view of the technologies and processes for energy generation as a path for waste treatment, presenting all the necessary information and tools for selecting the most sustainable waste-to-energy solution under varying conditions. The book combines methods such as lifecycle assessment, sustainability assessment, multi-criteria decision-making, and multi-objective optimization modes. In addition, it provides an overview of waste-to-energy feedstocks, technologies and implementation, then goes on to investigate the critical factors and key enablers that influence the sustainable development of the waste-to-energy industry. The book proposes several decision-making methods for the ranking and selection of waste-to-energy scenarios under different levels of certainty and information availability, including multi-criteria, multi-actor and multi-attribute methods. Finally, the book employs lifecycle tools that allow the assessment of economic, environmental and social sustainability of waste-to-energy systems. Explores existing and state-of-the-art waste to energy technologies and systems, as well as their feedstock requirements Presents a wide perspective of sustainability issues of waste-to-energy technologies, also discussing critical influential factors or key enablers for promoting the sustainable development of waste-to-energy solutions Provides multi-dimensional decision-making techniques for choosing the most suitable and sustainable waste-to-energy technologies for different scenarios


Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis under uncertainty in sustainable construction: a neutrosophic modified best-worst method

Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis under uncertainty in sustainable construction: a neutrosophic modified best-worst method

Author: Scherz M.

Publisher: Infinite Study

Published:

Total Pages: 10

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Capturing uncertainty in multiple criteria decision analysis (MCDA) is not a new theme but a largely developing topic which is in close connection with uncertainty theories such as fuzzy set and grey systems theories. Due to growing complexity of construction processes mainly because of implementation of sustainability aspects it would be necessary to take advantage of a novel MCDA methodology as an efficient tool to handle the uncertainty in sustainable construction decision making. In this study, we utilise a novel neutrosophic modified best-worst method (NM-BWM) to deal with the uncertainty in decision making in the context of sustainable construction. The method is an integration of neutrosophic set theory (NST) and the modified best-worst method (M-BWM). The NST can provide insights on efficient uncertainty handling of decision makers (DMs) subjective judgements. The BWM is a MCDA method which utilises two vectors of pairwise comparisons (the best criterion to others and others to the worst criterion) to obtain the weights of evaluation criteria. Merits of the BWM include its capability in effectively remedying the inconsistency derived from pairwise comparisons as well as simplicity and less pairwise comparisons compared to other similar methods like analytic hierarchy process (AHP). We show the applicability of the method in a case study with focus on the implementation of sustainable construction.